Post solidarity (?)
There’s enough dissing of cultural studies in the blogosphere to make me want to get therapy. Seriously: if anyone has reason to hate cultural studies, it’s me. It stole my social life. It made me move state twice. It pushes me to work the longest hours. And it’s making me blinder every year. But I don’t blame it. It’s not even a thing. I’d like to know what cultural studies ever promised – as if ‘it’ could, as if ‘it’ has enough coherence in any regional let alone national context to be accountable to any of the charges people persist in levelling at ‘it’ – that makes people so pissed off, aggressive or disappointed.
If expectant mums can have support groups to break the isolation of having a baby, can I start one to deal with being a blogger and writing a book about cultural studies? It could be just like a mothers’ group. We could meet at the local community centre and do stretching exercises and learn how to breathe under pain and stress… we could take walks in the park and sit on benches talking through each tiny trauma that’s developed since we last met which could affect the health of the baby. We could cook meals for each other so that we felt cared for; we could make phone calls in the afternoon to help with the constant doubts. We could even go out together on Friday and Saturday nights so we didn’t feel so pathetic and lonely – and go home kinda earlyish without having to make up excuses about why. We would understand each other, because we would know what the other is going through.
Imagine that. Imagine wanting to empathise with someone. Imagine wanting to hear someone say something positive. Imagine thinking that solidarity in writing and intellectual life and, you know, life generally, might be possible. I do all the time. I wish I didn’t have to. Oh – but maybe it’s why I spend so much time reading cultural studies?
Your Comments
John Gunders writes:
Yes, I agree: CS does come in for a lot of bashing, especially from within (how come historians don’t diss their own discipline?).
But then, things that don’t matter to us tend not to piss us off, or make us aggressive or disappointed. So maybe the navel-gazing and brow-beating is a sign that CS is having an effect: even it that’s mainly by getting up people’s noses! And maybe the undue attention that is paid to CS by people like Robert Bolt and the divine Miranda is a sign that we are doing some good in the world.
But yes, I’d love to join a CS expectant mum’s club, and talk about the price of nappies, when to introduce solids, and cracked nipples (or at least, their CS equivalents).
Posted: 21 11 2005 - 22:04 | Permanent link to this comment
Commenting is closed for this article.